| Date | City/Stadium | Winner | Runner-Up | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| June 23, 1988 | Edmonton, AB Commonwealth Stadium |
CFL All-Stars – 15 | Edmonton Eskimos – 4 | 27,573 |
| Dec. 3, 1983 | Vancouver, BC BC Place Stadium |
West All-Stars – 25 | East All-Stars – 15 | 14,000 |
| June 3, 1978 | Calgary, AB McMahon Stadium |
West All-Stars – 24 | East All-Stars – 12 | 21,000 |
| June 4, 1977 | Toronto, ON Exhibition Stadium |
East All-Stars – 20 | West All-Stars – 19 | 7,500 |
| May 29, 1976 | Edmonton, AB Clarke Stadium |
West All-Stars – 27 | East All-Stars – 16 | 21,762 |
| June 26, 1974 | Ottawa, ON Lansdowne Park |
Ottawa Rough Riders – 25 | CFL All-Stars – 22 | 15,102 |
| June 27, 1973 | Hamilton, ON Ivor Wynne Stadium |
CFL All-Stars – 22 | Hamilton Tiger-Cats – 11 | 24,765 |
| June 28, 1972 | Calgary, AB McMahon Stadium |
Calgary Stampeders – 23 | CFL All-Stars – 22 | 23,616 |
| June 29, 1971 | Montreal, QC Autostade |
CFL All-Stars – 30 | Montreal Alouettes – 13 | 9,000 |
| July 2, 1970 | Ottawa, ON Lansdowne Park |
CFL All-Stars – 35 | Ottawa Rough Riders – 14 | 23,094 |
| Dec. 6, 1958 | Hamilton, ON Civic Stadium |
WIFU All-Stars – 9 | IRFU All-Stars – 3 | 7,000 |
| Dec. 7, 1957 | Montreal, QC Percival Molson Memorial Stadium |
IRFU All-Stars – 20 | WIFU All-Stars – 2 | 5,000 |
| Dec. 8, 1956 | Vancouver, BC Empire Stadium |
WIFU All-Stars – 35 | IRFU All-Stars – 0 | 13,546 |
| Dec. 3, 1955 | Vancouver, BC Empire Stadium |
WIFU All-Stars – 6 | IRFU All-Stars – 6 | 15,088 |
| Aug. 22, 1953 | Hamilton, ON Civic Stadium |
Hamilton Tiger-Cats – 36 | Canadian All-Stars/Imperials – 5 | 15,000 |