| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| QB | Bernie Faloney | HAM |
| HB | Dick Shatto* | TOR |
| HB (plunging) | Gerry McDougall | HAM |
| HB | Joel Wells | MTL |
| FW | Ron Howell | HAM |
| E | Paul Dekker | HAM |
| E | John “Red” O'Quinn, Jr. | MTL |
| C | Tom Hugo, Jr. (Tie) | MTL |
| C | Norm Stoneburgh (Tie) | TOR |
| G | Hardiman Cureton | OTT |
| G | Jackie Simpson | MTL |
| T | John Barrow | HAM |
| T | Dick Fouts | TOR |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| DT | John Barrow | HAM |
| DT | Milt Graham | OTT |
| DE | Doug McNichol | MTL |
| DE | Pete Neumann | HAM |
| DG | Vince “Boomer” Scott | HAM |
| DG | Jackie Simpson | MTL |
| SEC | Tony Curcillo, Jr. | HAM |
| SEC | Tom Hugo, Jr. | MTL |
| DHB | Ralph Goldston | HAM |
| DHB | Eddie Macon | HAM |
| DHB | Hal “Prince” Patterson | MTL |
| S | Bob Simpson | OTT |
* – indicates unanimous selection
See an error? Please review sources and send corrections.
| Player | Season | Division Selection |
|---|---|---|
| Barrow, John | 2nd | 4th |
| Curcillo, Tony Jr. | 3rd | 2nd |
| Cureton, Hardiman | 3rd | 2nd |
| Dekker, Paul | 3rd | 1st |
| Faloney, Bernie | 3rd | 1st |
| Fouts, Dick | 2nd | 1st |
| Goldston, Ralph | 3rd | 3rd |
| Graham, Milt | 3rd | 1st |
| Howell, Ron | 5th | 1st |
| Hugo, Tom Jr. | 6th | 11th |
| Macon, Eddie | 3rd | 2nd |
| McDougall, Gerry | 2nd | 2nd |
| McNichol, Doug | 6th | 4th |
| Neumann, Pete | 8th | 6th |
| O'Quinn, John “Red” Jr. | 7th | 5th |
| Patterson, Hal “Prince” | 5th | 7th |
| Scott, Vince “Boomer” | 10th | 9th |
| Shatto, Dick | 5th | 3rd |
| Simpson, Bob | 10th | 7th |
| Simpson, Jackie | 1st | 2nd |
| Stoneburgh, Norm | 5th | 1st |
| Wells, Joel | 2nd | 1st |
Number of times player, through 1958, has been selected to First Team Division All-Star teams. Named to divisional team on offense and defense counts as two selections.
Note: All-Canadian selections began in 1962, division selections began in 1932 (IRFU) and 1937 (WIFU).
| Team | Division Selections |
|---|---|
| Hamilton Tiger-Cats | 11 |
| Montreal Alouettes | 8 |
| Ottawa RedBlacks | 3 |
| Toronto Argonauts | 3 |