QB Bernie Faloney HAM
HB Dick Shatto* TOR
HB (plunging) Gerry McDougall HAM
HB Joel Wells MTL
FW Ron Howell HAM
E Paul Dekker HAM
E John “Red” O'Quinn, Jr. MTL
C Tom Hugo, Jr. (Tie) MTL
C Norm Stoneburgh (Tie) TOR
G Hardiman Cureton OTT
G Jackie Simpson MTL
T John Barrow HAM
T Dick Fouts TOR
DT John Barrow HAM
DT Milt Graham OTT
DE Doug McNichol MTL
DE Pete Neumann HAM
DG Vince “Boomer” Scott HAM
DG Jackie Simpson MTL
SEC Tony Curcillo, Jr. HAM
SEC Tom Hugo, Jr. MTL
DHB Ralph Goldston HAM
DHB Eddie Macon HAM
DHB Hal “Prince” Patterson MTL
S Bob Simpson OTT

* – indicates unanimous selection

See an error? Please review sources and send corrections.

Conference Breakdown

Career to 1958 IRFU Player All-Star Selections

Player Season Division Selection
Barrow, John 2nd 4th
Curcillo, Tony Jr. 3rd 2nd
Cureton, Hardiman 3rd 2nd
Dekker, Paul 3rd 1st
Faloney, Bernie 3rd 1st
Fouts, Dick 2nd 1st
Goldston, Ralph 3rd 3rd
Graham, Milt 3rd 1st
Howell, Ron 5th 1st
Hugo, Tom Jr. 6th 11th
Macon, Eddie 3rd 2nd
McDougall, Gerry 2nd 2nd
McNichol, Doug 6th 4th
Neumann, Pete 8th 6th
O'Quinn, John “Red” Jr. 7th 5th
Patterson, Hal “Prince” 5th 7th
Scott, Vince “Boomer” 10th 9th
Shatto, Dick 5th 3rd
Simpson, Bob 10th 7th
Simpson, Jackie 1st 2nd
Stoneburgh, Norm 5th 1st
Wells, Joel 2nd 1st

Number of times player, through 1958, has been selected to First Team Division All-Star teams. Named to divisional team on offense and defense counts as two selections.

Note: All-Canadian selections began in 1962, division selections began in 1932 (IRFU) and 1937 (WIFU).

1958 IRFU Team All-Star Selections

Team Division Selections
Hamilton Tiger-Cats 11
Montreal Alouettes 8
Ottawa RedBlacks 3
Toronto Argonauts 3



  • No contributors for this game.