- 42nd Bob Dyce
(Oct. 1, 2022 – Present)
- 41st Paul LaPolice
(Dec. 9, 2019 – Oct. 1, 2022)
- 40th Rick Campbell
(Dec. 6, 2013 – Nov. 4, 2019)
- 39th John Jenkins
(Nov. 7, 2005 – April 9, 2006)
- 38th Joe Paopao
(Dec. 18, 2001 – Nov. 7, 2005)
- 37th John Payne
(July 4, 1996 – Feb. 1, 1997)
- 36th Jim Gilstrap
(March 23, 1995 – July 4, 1996)
- 35th Adam Rita
(Feb. 16, 1994 – Feb. 14, 1995)
- 34th Ron Smeltzer
(Feb. 10, 1992 – Nov. 22, 1993)
- 33rd Joe Faragalli
(Aug. 5, 1991 – Nov. 27, 1991)
- 32nd Steve Goldman
(Dec. 14, 1988 – Aug. 3, 1991)
- 31st Bob Weber
(July 28, 1988 – Dec. 6, 1988)
- 30th Fred Glick
(Feb. 10, 1987 – July 28, 1988)
- 29th Tom Dimitroff, Sr.
(Sept. 29, 1986 – Dec. 8, 1986)
- 28th Joe Moss
(Dec. 18, 1984 – Sept. 29, 1986)
- 27th George Brancato
(March 1, 1974 – Nov. 9, 1984)
- 26th Jack “Jocko” Gotta
(Dec. 10, 1969 – Feb. 4, 1974)
- 25th Frank Clair
(Dec. 12, 1955 – Dec. 10, 1969)
- 24th Chan Caldwell
(Jan. 1, 1955 – Dec. 12, 1955)
- 23rd Clem Crowe
(Jan. 1, 1951 – Nov. 18, 1954)
- 22nd Wally Masters
(1948 – 1950)
- 21st Sam Fox
(1947)
- 20th George Fraser
(1946)
- 19th Ross Trimble
(1945)
- 18th George Fraser
(1942)
- 17th Ross Trimble
(1937 – 1941)
- 16th Wilfred “Billy” Hughes
(1935 – 1936)
- 15th Wally Masters
(1933 – 1934)
- 14th Dave McCann
(1931 – 1932)
- 13th Dr. Andy Davies
(1930)
- 12th Joe Miller
(1929)
- 11th Walter Gilhooley
(1928)
- 10th Dave McCann
(1924 – 1927)
- 9th Sylvester “Silver” Quilty
(1923)
- 8th Tom “King” Clancy
(1921 – 1922)
- 7th Sylvester “Silver” Quilty
(1920)
- 6th Dave McCann
(1919)
- 5th Frank “Shag” Shaughnessy, Sr.
(1915)
- 4th Eddie Gerard
(1914)
- 3rd Rev. Father W. J. Stanton
(1913)
- 2nd Dr. Eugene “Doc” Galvin
(1912)
- 1st Tom “King” Clancy
(1904 – 1911)
1 – Interim