Roster and game participation numbers courtesy the CFL. All errors or omissions not in the original source are the responsibility of CFLdb Statistics, please report them.
| Jersey | Name | Position | Experience League (Team) |
Age† | Regular GP |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 64 | Bennett, Pete | T | 10th (10th) | 30 ‡ | Toronto (UofT) | 14 |
| 87 | Brewer, Ron | HB | R (1st) | 21 | Toronto Parkdale Lions Jr. | 14 |
| 77 | Buntins, Arvyd | E | 2nd (2nd) | 21 ‡ | Humberside HS (Toronto, ON) | 14 |
| 81 | Caraway, Donnie | HB, P | R (1st) | 24 | Houston | 9 |
| 82 | Carter, Boyd | E, HB | 2nd (2nd) | 23 ‡ | Santa Monica CC | 14 |
| 65 | Casey, John | G | R (1st) | 23 | Toronto (UofT) | 14 |
| 41 | Cowart, Larry | C | R (1st) | 22 | Baylor | 8 |
| 63 | DeLuca, Sam | G | 2nd (2nd) | 22 | South Carolina | 6 |
| 53 | DeLucca, Jerry | G | R (1st) | 22 | Middle Tennessee State | 4 |
| 86 | Doucette, Gerry | QB | 5th (5th) | 24 ‡ | Etobicoke HS (Etobicoke, ON) | 14 |
| 97 | Elias, Louie | HB | R (1st) | 22 ‡ | California-Los Angeles (UCLA) | 10 |
| 93 | Exelby, Clare | HB | R (1st) | 19 | Toronto Parkdale Lions Jr. | 14 |
| 76 | Fedor, Paul | E | R (1st) | 24 | Queen's | 13 |
| 69 | Fouts, Dick | T | 2nd (2nd) | 24 | Missouri | 14 |
| 70 | Hair, Henry | E | 2nd (2nd) | 26 | Georgia Tech | 6 |
| 92 | Knox, Ronnie | QB | 2nd (1st) | 23 | California-Los Angeles (UCLA) | 8 |
| 52 | Kristopaitis, Vic | G, K | 2nd (2nd) | 22 | Dayton | 14 |
| 95 | Kuntz, Bobby | HB | 3rd (3rd) | 26 | McMaster | 14 |
| 91 | Mann, Dave | HB, P | R (1st) | 26 | Oregon State | 12 |
| 97 | Meserve, Reg | HB | 2nd (2nd) | 23 ‡ | Western Tech HS (Toronto, ON) | 2 |
| 99 | Muntz, Phil | HB | 2nd (1st) | 24 | Toronto (UofT) | 13 |
| 61 | Novis, Bert | G | R (1st) | 27 | Central Tech HS (Toronto, ON) | 10 |
| 60 | Nykoluk, Dan | T | 3rd (3rd) | 25 | R. H. King Academy HS (Toronto, ON) | 10 |
| 73 | O'Garro, Pete | E | 2nd (2nd) | 27 | California-Los Angeles (UCLA) | 8 |
| 62 | Oliver, Bobby Jack | G | R (1st) | 22 | Baylor | 13 |
| 89 | Philp, Gerry | HB | R (1st) | 26 | Florida State | 14 |
| 80 | Ponton, Alex Jr. | HB | 7th (5th) | 27 | McMaster | 14 |
| 90 | Roberts, C.R. | HB | 2nd (2nd) | 22 | Southern California (USC) | 8 |
| 53 | Robinson, Fred II | G | 2nd (1st) | 27 | Washington | 9 |
| 84 | Rountree, Jim | HB | R (1st) | 22 | Florida | 7 |
| 79 | Schriewer, Menan “Tex” | E | 3rd (3rd) | 23 | Texas | 14 |
| 88 | Shatto, Dick | HB | 5th (5th) | 25 | Kentucky | 14 |
| 40 | Stoneburgh, Norm | C | 4th (4th) | 23 | Toronto Parkdale Lions Jr. | 14 |
| 83,92 | Tharp, Thomas “Corky” | HB | 2nd (3rd) | 27 | Alabama | 6 |
| 98 | Trivisonno, Joe | HB | R (1st) | 25 | Ohio State | 4 |
| 72 | Welton, John | E | 7th (4th) | 28 | Wake Forest | 14 |
† – Age at start of 1958 season (Aug. 14, 1958).
‡ – Exact birth date unknown. Age is approximate and may be ±1 year or more.