QB Bernie Custis HAM
HB Billy Bass TOR
HB Ulysses “Crazy Legs” Curtis TOR
HB Hal Waggoner HAM
FW Bruce Cummings OTT
SN Ed “Buckets” Hirsch TOR
IW Eddie Bevan HAM
IW Ray Cicia MTL
MW Jack Carpenter HAM
MW Bob Gain OTT
OW Vince Mazza HAM
OW Bob Simpson OTT

* – indicates unanimous selection

See an error? Please review sources and send corrections.

Conference Breakdown

Career to 1951 IRFU Player All-Star Selections

Player Season Division Selection
Bass, Billy 3rd 1st
Bevan, Eddie 7th 1st
Carpenter, Jack 2nd 1st
Cicia, Ray 2nd 2nd
Cummings, Bruce 2nd 1st
Curtis, Ulysses “Crazy Legs” 2nd 2nd
Custis, Bernie 1st 1st
Gain, Bob 1st 1st
Hirsch, Ed “Buckets” 2nd 2nd
Mazza, Vince 2nd 2nd
Simpson, Bob 3rd 1st
Waggoner, Hal 1st 1st

Number of times player, through 1951, has been selected to First Team Division All-Star teams. Named to divisional team on offense and defense counts as two selections.

Note: All-Canadian selections began in 1962, division selections began in 1932 (IRFU) and 1937 (WIFU).

1951 IRFU Team All-Star Selections

Team Division Selections
Hamilton Tiger-Cats 5
Ottawa RedBlacks 3
Toronto Argonauts 3
Montreal Alouettes 1


  • Windsor Star
  • CFL Facts, Figures and Records, 1985-2016 Editions


  • No contributors.